Versus > Brotato vs PAYDAY 2
Head to head
Brotato vs PAYDAY 2
Both games go deep on gunplay, build customization and loot & itemization. Brotato puts far more into roguelike runs. PAYDAY 2 puts far more into co-op pve, stealth and immersive-sim reactivity. They ask for about the same amount of grind (4.9 and 5.1 out of 10).
Move by move
Depth 0-10 for each mechanicBrotatoPAYDAY 2
8
Roguelike Runs 0
Roguelike Runs: Brotato 8, PAYDAY 2 0 out of 10. 7
Gunplay 8
Gunplay: Brotato 7, PAYDAY 2 8 out of 10. 6
Precision & Skill Difficulty 8
Precision & Skill Difficulty: Brotato 6, PAYDAY 2 8 out of 10. 5
Skill Trees & Progression 8
Skill Trees & Progression: Brotato 5, PAYDAY 2 8 out of 10. 0
Co-op PvE 8
Co-op PvE: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 8 out of 10. 7
Build Customization 7
Build Customization: Brotato 7, PAYDAY 2 7 out of 10. 6
Loot & Itemization 7
Loot & Itemization: Brotato 6, PAYDAY 2 7 out of 10. 0
Stealth 7
Stealth: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 7 out of 10. 3
Mod Ecosystem 6
Mod Ecosystem: Brotato 3, PAYDAY 2 6 out of 10. 1
Horror & Tension 4
Horror & Tension: Brotato 1, PAYDAY 2 4 out of 10. 1
Story-Driven 4
Story-Driven: Brotato 1, PAYDAY 2 4 out of 10. 0
Immersive-Sim Reactivity 4
Immersive-Sim Reactivity: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 4 out of 10. 0
Time Pressure 4
Time Pressure: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 4 out of 10. 3
Boss Encounters 2
Boss Encounters: Brotato 3, PAYDAY 2 2 out of 10. 3
Economy & Trading 2
Economy & Trading: Brotato 3, PAYDAY 2 2 out of 10. 1
Environmental Storytelling 3
Environmental Storytelling: Brotato 1, PAYDAY 2 3 out of 10. 1
Puzzle Solving 3
Puzzle Solving: Brotato 1, PAYDAY 2 3 out of 10. 1
Lore Depth 3
Lore Depth: Brotato 1, PAYDAY 2 3 out of 10. 0
Procedural Generation 3
Procedural Generation: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 3 out of 10. 0
Melee Combat 3
Melee Combat: Brotato 0, PAYDAY 2 3 out of 10. Quick answers
Built from both scansIs Brotato like PAYDAY 2?
On mechanics they are a 74% match. Both games go deep on gunplay, build customization and loot & itemization.
Should I play Brotato or PAYDAY 2?
Pick Brotato if you want roguelike runs; pick PAYDAY 2 if you want co-op pve and stealth. Neither is better overall; they lean on different things.
Which is grindier, Brotato or PAYDAY 2?
Neither stands out: their core mechanics average 4.9 and 5.1 out of 10 for grind.

